Evidence
What the evidence shows
Both serums are well-formulated, but the "better" one depends entirely on your skin type. Derma Co leans toward oil-control, Plum leans toward hydration and barrier support.
Use this section to decide
Does this advice apply to me?
Find the concern or goal closest to yours, then use the fit signal to decide how much weight to give this guide.If your goal is
Derma Co best forUsually relevant- Fit signal
- Often useful
Oily, acne-prone
If your goal is
Plum best forUsually relevant- Fit signal
- Often useful
Dry, combination
If your goal is
ConcentrationDepends- Fit signal
- Possible fit
Both 10%
If your goal is
Key differenceUse caution- Fit signal
- Limited evidence
Zinc (Derma) vs. Ceramides (Plum)
Practical use
How to use it
Assess your skin type
Are you oily/acne-prone or dry/combination? This will guide your choice.
Consider your tolerance
If you have sensitive skin or are new to niacinamide, consider a lower concentration first.
Match the formulation to your skin
Choose Derma Co for oil-control, Plum for hydration and barrier support.
Safety
Side effects and cautions
- Choosing based only on brand popularity
Match the formulation to your skin type for better results.
- Thinking both are interchangeable
The supporting ingredients make them suitable for different skin types.
- Jumping straight to 10% without trying lower concentrations first
Consider starting with a 5% serum if you're new to niacinamide.
Fit
Who should be careful
- Those sensitive to 10% niacinamide - consider lower concentration
Worth noting
Small details that can change the answer
- Derma Co Focus. Oil-control and soothing with zinc and cica.
- Plum Focus. Hydration and barrier support with rice water and ceramides.
- Concentration. Both use 10% niacinamide, which is high.
- Key Consideration. 10% may irritate sensitive skin - start with caution.
Derma Co's serum is better for oily, acne-prone skin due to zinc PCA and cica.
Plum's serum is better for dry or combination skin due to rice water and ceramides.
Both use 10% niacinamide, which may be high for sensitive skin.
Choose based on your skin type and concerns, not just brand popularity.
Consider a 5% serum first if you're new to niacinamide.
Ingredient Comparison
Derma Co vs. Plum: Ingredient comparison
Derma Co 10% Niacinamide Serum
bestBest for: Oily, acne-prone, and combination skinZinc PCA for oil regulation and acne control ยท Cica (Centella asiatica) for soothing and healing ยท Hyaluronic acid for balanced hydration ยท Watery, lightweight texture suitable for oily skin
Limitations: 10% concentration may be high for sensitive skin ยท May not be hydrating enough for very dry skinPlum 10% Niacinamide Serum
goodBest for: Dry, combination, and sensitive skin (if tolerated)Rice water for brightening and nourishment ยท Ceramides for barrier support ยท Hyaluronic acid for hydration ยท Softer, more hydrating texture
Limitations: 10% concentration may be high for sensitive skin ยท Not as oil-controlling for very oily skinExplanation
The 10% concentration consideration
Both serums use 10% niacinamide, which is at the high end of what's available over the counter. While research has been done on 10% concentrations, the studies show that 2-5% is sufficient for most people and that higher percentages offer minimal additional benefit while increasing irritation risk. If you're new to niacinamide or have sensitive skin, consider starting with a 5% serum before trying these 10% formulations.
Decision Helper
Which should you choose?
You have oily, acne-prone skin with active breakouts
Derma Co's zinc and cica formulationThe zinc PCA helps control oil and calm inflammation, while cica promotes healing.
You have dry or combination skin that needs barrier support
Plum's rice water and ceramide formulationCeramides support the barrier while rice water provides brightening and nourishment.
You have sensitive skin or are new to niacinamide
Neither - try a 5% serum first10% is more likely to cause irritation in sensitive or inexperienced skin.
Questions
Frequently asked questions
Which one is better for acne-prone skin?
Derma Co's zinc PCA formulation is better for acne-prone skin due to its oil-regulating and anti-inflammatory properties.
Which one is better for sensitive skin?
Both are 10% and may irritate sensitive skin. Consider a lower concentration serum instead.
Can I use both serums?
No - using both would be redundant and increase irritation risk. Choose one.
Which serum is more hydrating?
Plum's serum with ceramides and rice water is more hydrating than Derma Co's oil-control formulation.
